Florida’s Hidden Insurer Report Is Out. Here’s What It Says?: the real signal is the immediate adjustment required in cash, risk, and execution

The Number That Leads

The core finding is blunt: Florida property insurers covered in the 2022 “Affiliated Fee Analysis” reported combined losses of approximately $432 million from 2017 to 2019, while their affiliated companies — sister entities receiving premium dollars for services like underwriting, claims handling, and IT — generated $1.3 billion in net income over the same period. The analysis was conducted by Risk & Regulatory Consulting (RRC) under a roughly $150,000 state contract and examined records across 53 Florida property insurers.

The report was completed in April 2022 and never released. It sat inside the Office of Insurance Regulation while policyholders absorbed successive premium increases, seven Florida-focused insurers went insolvent between 2021 and 2022, and Tallahassee passed major legal reforms that industry observers say helped stabilize — and protect — the market as it existed. The Orlando Sentinel and South Florida Sun Sentinel obtained the full report through a public records request. The Florida Senate then demanded its destruction. The news organizations published it anyway on September 25, 2026.

What Sits Behind the Number

The affiliate structure at issue is legal and widely used. An insurer’s affiliate — sharing common ownership — handles operational functions and charges fees for those services. Florida law requires those payments to be “fair and reasonable,” but no state statute defines those terms with measurable precision. That definitional gap is where the problem lives.

The consultant flagged 20 of the 53 companies as paying affiliates at rates presumed not to be fair and reasonable, based on a direct comparison between what the insurer reported in losses and what its affiliates took home. In at least 17 cases, the insurer publicly reported operating losses while simultaneously paying affiliates more than the total losses they claimed.

Two examples illustrate the scale. Security First Insurance reported approximately $27 million in losses while its affiliates, receiving 30% of the insurer’s gross written premiums, earned more than $50 million in net income. PURE Insurance, a high-net-worth carrier, reported $9 million in losses while affiliates taking 22% of gross premiums earned $176 million. In both cases, the consultant’s finding was the same: affiliate payments presumed not to be fair and reasonable.

Insurers named in the report have disputed the methodology. Security First’s CEO argues the analysis misses the full financial picture, noting his company lost approximately $150 million from 2017 to 2022 and required significant owner capital injections. PURE’s spokesperson called the presumption in an unfinished draft insufficient to constitute a finding. HCI Group’s CEO said the consultant’s standard was arbitrary and inconsistently applied. State regulators have called the report “incredibly flawed and outdated.” The consultant, for her part, told lawmakers in April 2025 she considered it complete and received no requests for changes from the state before it was shelved.

What This Is Worth in Your Operation

For a South Florida business owner renewing commercial property or business owner’s insurance in 2026, this matters in practical terms. The Sentinel/Sun Sentinel’s own analysis of publicly available 2025 data found that affiliate payments by key Florida insurers still range from 20% to 35% of direct premium — essentially unchanged from the 2017–2019 levels the consultant examined. Affiliate profit figures are not publicly disclosed, so the true current margin split between insurer and affiliate remains unverifiable by policyholders or their brokers.

That opacity has a direct consequence. When an insurer files for a rate increase citing underwriting losses, those losses are calculated at the primary insurer level — not across the combined entity. If a substantial share of premium revenue flows to a profitable affiliate before the primary insurer’s financials are calculated, the reported losses can look larger than the consolidated operation actually experiences. Policyholders, including business owners purchasing commercial lines, are paying rates informed by that reported figure.

Florida regulators do review affiliate contracts and have, according to state officials, forced some to be unwound — but those actions are confidential. No public record allows a business owner, broker, or attorney to evaluate whether a given carrier’s affiliate fees have been scrutinized or cleared. That is the structural asymmetry this report makes visible.

What the Data Does Not Say

The RRC analysis covers 2017 to 2019 — a window that precedes the worst of the market dislocation that followed Hurricanes Irma and Michael. Reinsurance costs surged in subsequent years, and Florida carriers faced a litigation environment that inflated claims costs substantially before legislative reforms addressed it in 2021 and 2022. The consultant’s methodology did not account for those pressures, and that is a legitimate limitation the industry has raised.

The report is also a draft that was never finalized, peer-reviewed, or subjected to a formal rebuttal process before being shelved. The consultant said she viewed it as complete; the state says it was not. That dispute has not been resolved. What is resolved: the Florida House voted 106–3 this year for legislation requiring insurers to submit more detailed affiliate payment disclosures and establishing evaluation standards — and the bill died in the Senate.

No updated forensic audit of affiliate payments has been completed. The House committed to one and appears to have abandoned it.

The Implementation Question

Before your next commercial insurance renewal, ask your broker one specific question: Can you show me this carrier’s affiliate structure, and has the Office of Insurance Regulation reviewed its affiliate agreements in the past three years?

If the answer is no or unknown, you are pricing a policy against a loss history that may not reflect the insurer’s consolidated financial position. That does not mean the carrier will fail to pay claims — but it does mean the premium justification you are being offered is based on numbers that exclude a significant and unregulated revenue stream within the same ownership group. Knowing which carriers have been scrutinized, even at a general level, is now a legitimate due-diligence question rather than an esoteric regulatory concern.

Sources

  • Orlandosentinel — News organizations publish Florida’s secret examination of insurer profits (Link)